Differences in the determination of manner of death for death certificates by physicians in South Korea: questionnaire survey

In South Korea, the manner and cause of death are determined by physicians. The present study aimed to investigate the differences in decisions made by physicians when completing death certificates and the factors that lead to these differences in South Korea. Questionnaires were used to survey 210 physicians who routinely complete death certificates, and demographic data along with information on their decisions regarding the manner and cause of death as well as natural and unnatural contributory causes were ascertained for eight representative cases. The study sample comprised 149 (71.0%) and 61 (29.0%) male and female physicians, respectively, and the mean age in this sample was 36.93 ± 4.51 years. We found that 64.7%, 61.4%, 7.6%, 4.3%, 4.3%, 65.7%, 84.3%and 53.3% of the physicians considered cases 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 as unnatural deaths, respectively, while 27.6%, 32.0%, 91.9%, 95%, 8.5%, 26.6%, 6.7% and 38.1%considered them to be natural deaths, respectively. In Case 5, 81.7% considered death to be due to an indeterminate cause. We found that differences may exist in how physicians select the manner of death when completing a death certificate and that this decision is influenced by several factors.

Cause of death certification; Death certificate; Manner of death certificate

[1] Brooks EG, Reed KD. Principles and pitfalls: a guide to death certification. Clinical Medicine & Research. 2015; 13: 74–82.

[2] Mieno MN, Tanaka N, Arai T, Kawahara T, Kuchiba A, Ishikawa S, et al. Accuracy of death certificates and assessment of factors for misclassification of underlying cause of death. Journal of Epidemiology. 2016; 26: 191–198.

[3] Kim KS, Lim YS, Rhee JE, Suh GJ, Youn YK, Eo EK, et al. Problems in completing a death certificate. Journal of the Korean Society of Emergency Medicine. 2000; 11: 443–449.

[4] Yoon SH, KIM R, LEE CS. Analysis of death certificate errors of a university hospital emergency room. Korean Journal of Legal Medicine. 2017; 41: 61–66.

[5] Dash SK, Behera BK, Patro S. Accuracy in certification of cause of death in a tertiary care hospital—a retrospective analysis. Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine. 2014; 24: 33–36.

[6] Kim H, Park J, Cho W, Seo J, Choi C, Na J. The discrepancy of the cause and manner of death between death certificates and autopsy reports. Korean Journal of Legal Medicine. 2014; 38: 139.

[7] Shin H, Lee S. How to write a death certificate: from a statistical point of view. Journal of the Korean Medical Association. 2018; 61: 268.

[8] Kang E, Lee H, Kim SH. The effect of education on ‘how to write the death certificate’ for resident trainees of the emergency department. Journal of the Korean Society of Emergency Medicine. 2018; 29: 529–550.

[9] Kim M, Lee SD. A proposal for writing a better death certificate. Journal of the Korean Medical Association. 2018; 61: 259.

[10] Lee H-J, Lee S-H. Inappropriateness in completing a death certificate. Journal of Forensic and Investigative Science. 2008; 3: 43–49.

[11] Association KM. How to write and issue medical certificates. Korean Medical Association: Seoul. 2015.

[12] Park WS, Lee MY, Lee MS, Yoon SC, Lee YS, Seo SW, et al. A study on the evaluation of the quality of death statistics and its improvement methods. Dankook University Medical College Health Promotion Agency Funds. 2003; 42–43.

[13] Legislation, K.M.o.G. Medical Service Act. Article 17 (medical certificates, etc.). Available at: http://www.law.go.kr/lsInfoP.do?lsiSeq=183558&urlMode=engLsInfoR&viewCls= engLsInfoR" (Accessed: 29 May 2016).

[14] Lim JY, Yang KM, Lee DH. Study on death certificates and postmortem examination certificates written by Korean emergency physicians. Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine. 2020; 72: 101960.

[15] Lu T, Shih T, Lee M, Chou M, Lin C. Diversity in death certification. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 2001; 54: 1086–1093.

[16] Roberts ISD. What is a natural cause of death? A survey of how coroners in England and Wales approach borderline cases. Journal of Clinical Pathology. 2000; 53: 367–373.

[17] Lu T, Kwok C, Ho L. Whether to report diabetes as the underlying cause-of-death? A survey of internists of different sub-specialties. BMC Endocrine Disorders. 2010; 10: 13.